Hinduism...If we take out Krishna from Mahabharata, would there have been a war?

If yes, who would have won it? If no, why?

if Krishna was out of Mahabharata than Thar wouldn't be any Mahabharata itself..

there is not much involvement of Krishna in Mahabharata . it was the fight between the pandas and guavas . Krishna was their uncle and gave away his army to the guavas as a help and Arjuna expected only his uncle's blessings . Krishna chose to be Arjuna's chariot driver

Adharma and Corruption of mind personified.Though he is the one who gave Geeta to the world, He took side of so called Pandavas( none of whom were born to Pandu), born out of Extra Maratial affairs of Kunti, and the rightful claimant of Kuru Dynasty-Duryodhana was eliminated with entire family just because they were born assures.There would have Ben no War at all. So everything is fair in War and Love.

Nodoubt, the Politicans follow the Legaccy of Krishna and those Selfappointead Religious Heads rise up with followers just like Krishna had many followers.

Krishna appears towards the end to give a finishing touch to the tussle between two warring groups- one personified as following all virtues and another following all vices. Vives outnumber virtues. Many a times Arjun and Bhim were showing their val our. It is hypothetical to ask what would have happened, for example if Karna remained with Pandavas. According to Hinduism the story happened and got recorded and has many moral and immoral messages.

Krishna was not responsible for the gambling episode and the dethroning of Pandavas. He (as an avatar) allowed things to happen, ripe and finally he did the surgery with his mastery strokes. Had he not been there, we would have had a dull history without any record

Not really. Cause Yudistra was all for peace and kindness and not taking what was his due, etc. I guess today a man like him would be called a fool. And his brothers even more fool for obeying his commands since he was the big brother. Krishna insinuated the war for panda to fight for their rights, but on a higher level, the reason was to get rid of bad blood, the imbalance that had set in, and to do that he needed a war, between the bad guys and the good guys. They may have went on crying at the JustiiCEOfll and may have let Duryodana get away with it all. Well this such a force a Bhisma fighting, I doubt even if they had got past him, had Krishna not told them about Shikandi being a woman reincarnated as a man. And as Bhisma would only put down weapons in front of a woman, Shikandi was responsible for getting rid of the big guy!

Friend,

IT IS PURELY A HYPOTHETICAL QUESTION AND THERE IS NO ANSWER TO SUCH QUESTION.

The Krishnaavataara was specially came on to Earth to Reduce Bhoo Bhaaram.

So the war was imminent.