Bukharists: Do you consider the Holy Quran insufficient in order to be Muslim?

Why do you need an unknown guy called Bukhari?

We need the Prophet -- peace be upon him and his family -- to elaborate the Quran... such as how to pray the prescribed Salat.

Cause Allah Taala himself said in Al Quraan itself that we need Hadith

hey year CD Kay Hal hair?

i have no thin 2 day about Bukhara, but i think looking at how the prophet and his family did certain things is important for Islam.

for example, the Goran says to pray 3 times a day - but it doesn't actually tell you how to pray.

and the Qumran doesn't tell us how to perform hajj - the Qumran could be considered insufficient here so to get the things we need a muslims, we use hadeeths and sonnah.

hope i helped xD salam.

No but cherry picking Quran (omitting the fact that Quran stipulates it necessary to follow the Prophet saw, therefore indirectly alludes to the Hadith) does not suffice to make you a Muslim and interpreting Quran to your convenience certainly suffices to categorize you as a non Muslim.

Without Hadith you have no source of history, no source of cont ex of revelation and therefore no framework to properly analyze Islam in its context.

Imam Al-Bukhari Hamillhull ahot unknown. But you have no knowledge, so obviously the issue isn't clear to you. And Allah swt commanded us to follow the Hadith - in fact, the Qur'an is also hadith as mentioned by Allah swt. And the Qur'an and Sunnah cannot be separated, just like the Qur'an and the Messenger (our beloved, Muhammad saws) who was sent to teach it cannot be separated.

??????? ????? ????????? ? ????????? ???????? ????? ?????????
12:77. ...He said (within himself): "You are in worst case, and All?h knows best the truth of what you assert!"

To learn the Qumran, you need:

a) an Arabic dictionary, classical and all the other variant dialects

b) knowledge of Arabic grammar

c) taffies history of the Qumran

d) every tool at ones disposal.

Quran 17:36 translation
And do not follow what you have no knowledge of; surely the hearing, the sight and the heart, all of these, shall be questioned about that.

@ Abba gab MO!...
How to pray according to the Hadiths depicts the same way that Arab Pagans pray.
Bukhari brings to light many pagan customs many of which were not accepted by Mohammad. Stoning people to death, cutting off the hands of thieves and killing reverts were not taught by the Prophet but Muslims today uphold those laws which are simply traditional Arabic laws and not Islamic.

He isn't unknown. You couldn't find anyone more reliable than him. Read his biography.

And the Quran was revealed in Arabic. Classical Arabic. Which means if it's just read as it is, unless you're highly educated, it can be difficult to understand the full meaning and context of its content.
Hadith helps by providing us with background knowledge of what happened and details of some events. Also, the next best source for knowledge after the Quran is the Prophet who lived his life by the Quran and followed it word for word. So obviously, whatever he did (what is narrated by Bukhari in Eadith) is what the Quran orders us to do.

Bukhari? Bukhari is far from unknown in the Muslim world. He is one of the most respected scholars, and his interpretations are used all over the world by practicing Muslims. I totally agree with Ahmed and Abdulmalik. The ArdathThnd Qur'an go together. And what are Bukharists?

Who taught u to read salaam, what breaks Ur salaam, SAM , how to perform hajj , etc?????????
And please do me a favor Imam Bukhari (RA) is not Ur friend or family member, pulse use his name with respect. Da enemy of Allah's Friends is an enemy of Allah. So take heed and be warned.

The ways and saying of Muhammed SAW are also the Quran so that is Al Sunnah Al Quran!
Al Quran Al Karim and Al Sunnah and there is nothing you or anyone that ever comes or came before that will ever do anything about that. Not now, not ever.

You lost again! How does it feel to be a failure everyday?

The Holy Quran is the first thing we turn to for guidance. It is the word of Allah.
Bukhari, Muslim, Tirmidhi, Abu Dawud, and all the others compiled Eadith, which are what the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) said, did, or approved.
As Muslims, we need to follow both. The Eadith offer interpretations to verses of the Quran. They also go more into detail than the Quran about certain things, such as how to pray Sal.

We can't follow the Quran and not the hadith or the other way around. We need to follow both to understand how to follow Islam the way it should be followed.

I don't. : ) Allah (Set) and Qur'an ALONE are enough for me. : ) Salam!